Everyone has their standard method of cooking a steak, usually I fry mine, some people grill them (or broil them), my mother-in-law* bakes them.

On New Year’s Day my she made steaks for 13 people by baking them! These are a definite crowd pleaser, and are much simpler than if you wanted to fry or grill that many steaks.

*(almost) mother-in-law, it might feel like it, but we aren’t married yet 🙂

Slow Baked Steaks


Now to make it perfectly clear, if you bake your steak it doesn’t taste the same. However different doesn’t mean bad! You won’t need a steak knife for these steaks, as they are cooked slower they are less tough and more melt-in-the-mouth. They taste more like roast beef.

Slow Baked Steaks Recipe

Cooking Time: 1 hour

  • Sirloin Steaks, one per person
  • 1 onion, sliced thinly, try not to break up the slices
  • 1 mushroom per person
  • 1/4 tsp of mustard, I used dijon
  • 1/2 tsp of Worcester sauce
  • Tin foil, to wrap each steak in

Prepare the tin foil by cutting sections big enough to wrap around each steak. Pre-heat the oven to 190 oC (375 oF).

In a frying pan brown the steaks for a minute each side on a high heat, then add some water, mustard and the Worcester sauce. Remove the steaks from the frying pan and place each on a sheet of tin foil.

Add the mushrooms to the liquid and leave to reduce, until thick. In the mean time top each steak with some sliced onion.

Browned Steak in Foil, topped with onions

Once the sauce has reduced top each steak with some of the liquid and mushrooms.

Steak and Mushrooms

Wrap each steak in the tin foil, using double folds at the edges to ensure the liquid can’t escape. Place on a baking tray and cook in the oven for at least 1 hour.

Steak all wrapped up in tin foil

They are cooked if you can easily cut through the steaks. To serve I made turnip chips and added a side of green beans.

Unwrapping the steak

Somehow fried Steaks makes me think of a special Saturday night dinner, a romantic evening in, this steak is definitely for Sundays. It’s relaxing, easy, comfort food.